NRL: Reactive is as Reactive does

NRL management never ceases to amaze me, and that’s unfortunate because I like being amazed … but in a positive way.

While the real NRL CEO, Cameron Smith is busy lifting trophies or talking about the Auckland 9’s (please Lord, no!) or Benny Barba, John Grant’s lunchboy has gone and forgotten to invite the game’s Immortals to the season launch. Sheesh!

I haven’t seen a more brain-dead decision since … since … since Anthony Mundine ignored 2 support players 5 metres from the line in a 3-on-1 situation in the 1999 Grand Final. I’m pretty sure 20-0 right after half-time would’ve shut the Storm out of that one, and I’m equally adamant that, while David Smith isn’t quite up there in that rarified air of decision-making, he needs to shut down the opportunities for negative press (like this blog, I suppose) and tighten the ship. Death by a thousand cuts is not a great way for the game to proceed.

I actually don’t envy David Smith’s position because he has moved into a position rife with legacy issues, and it’s clearly too difficult to buy good enough help to inform him what an Immortal is (hint: not Christopher Lambert). Lucky for him that other chap, what’s his name, Gallop, had the TV rights pretty much sealed before he was ‘proactively’ let loose to really threaten the NRL (seen the Wanderers and FC lately?) otherwise the workload would be unbearable!

Coincidentally, I’m sure the existence of these pre-existing issues is one of the reasons Todd Greenberg decided to bide his time with the Bulldogs before taking the top job (and I’m sure it’s a matter of time). The prospect of moving into a position where he has less power and influence, little scope for creativity, and the monumental headache of taking the blame for the persistent issues like player welfare and concussion that should have been dealt with years ago is nowhere near as much fun as poking yourself in the eye repeatedly with a fork. He’s smart. I’d prefer he was ARLC Chairman, but that’s another matter …

What have I done.?! Get me back to Lloyds!

What have I done.?! Get me back to Lloyds!

Given his banking history, David might have had a few knocks around the melon himself, probably by a blunt object called Libor, to the point where he’s beginning to look a little too much like Harry Potter, the Maxwell Smart of wizards. He will earn that comparison as CEO if he doesn’t get on the front foot and initiate a calculated process to deal with issues surrounding concussion. Previous administrators have not tackled this issue either, but it might have got him off to a ‘proactive’ start. Do what a new government does. Claim a massive budget black hole and start again. He can do the same, though I’m not sure he’s allowed …

In any case, there’s a very tight constraint on how proactive you can be when you don’t really understand the game, but concussion is a no-brainer.

Consider what the US has gone through on this subject – deaths and serial depressions of former professional players. Class action lawsuits have resulted, leading now to studies into youth concussion and other rigorous research that hope to put all the pieces together. It’s a shame some of those lives can’t be restored in the same way.

This is the type of research that the NRL betrays no sign of understanding. It certainly has done nothing about it publicly. It has banned the shoulder charge, but totally missed the point that head contact, in all forms, is the real issue.

I’ll be interested to see what penalties are handed out for high shots this year (guessing they are nowhere near fitting the crime, or true to the theme of caring about the effects of concussion). If the NRL is interested in results, it has to lead. It’s that simple.

Speaking of which …

The Papalii shuffle

This knocked me off my perch the other day. Josh Papalii doing the Gangnam style with a pen in each hand, it seems. How can the season be yet to start and a player has swapped allegiances? Not now, mind you, but for next year. And now it’s just another bad soap opera tug of war. Hoodathunkit? It gets earlier every year. Pretty soon they’ll announce 2yrs in advance!

It’s useful to understand that rugby league players are not like normal employees. They’re contractors. A standard rugby league contract may read as though they are employees, complete with annual leave, but they’re not. After you’ve done your time, the club either wants to keep you … or not. They also have the added responsibility of being contracted as part of a team where, in theory, the cream rises to the top when the performance of said team is greater than the sum of its parts. So this is also a team issue.

The Papalii episode is worse than the Star Wars episodes 1, 2 & 3 combined. Actually, that’s not possible. The point is, a balance needs to be struck between the interests of players, clubs and those other stakeholders whose name escapes me … oh yeah, the fans.

It’s hard to be critical of someone looking out for their future, but it does leave a sour taste for fans to see a player who may not have the incentive to be fully engaged for an entire season knowing that their future lay elsewhere, particularly if the team is losing.

Get the transfer window in place. It doesn’t have to be a free-for-all over a weekend, but refuse to register any contracts signed outside the month of July in the case of a player going to another club.

A player will get the message if his club hasn’t re-signed him by, say, May, but as long as everyone understands nothing is binding until that period, they can have their little clandestine meetings as often as they like, and leak the details if it suits. It’s not too late to interfere with semi-finals, and it’s also early enough to ward off other sports (which is an overblown fear anyway).

BowdenPrescription to NRL management: 1 Uppercut, twice daily for two weeks. If current lethargy persists, take another course. Repeat until sensible. Or concussed.


6 thoughts on “NRL: Reactive is as Reactive does

  1. Knee jerk reactions, incompetence, ignoring the science on concussion, this isn’t the problem with Rugby League, this is the glory of Rugby League. As for Greenberg, heaven help the greatest game of all if it is suddenly run by someone with conviction, ethics & vision. Who would have watched the Chaser if it was run by Kerry O’Brien? Viva la Theatre of Rugby League.

    • Funny you say that because I missed putting in a line that I had intended to … Essentially asking is this WHY rugby league succeeds despite its management? Can’t disagree. As for Toddy, probably too sensible, you may be right.

      Stay tuned for the post the betting agencies don’t want you to see … The Dr’s 2013 home and away season placings.

      Sent from my iPhone

  2. I think David Smith has a very good business mind. So he hasn’t got the knowledge of the game yet, he’s been in the job for how long? Gallop was there too long, we need a fresh mind with fresh ideas. Give him time. Then if he hasn’t produced, we can drive him out with pitchforks and lanterns.

    As for the transfer window, I don’t see how this will really work. Players have a finite time in the game and are looking to secure as much money and as long a career as they can. The NRL only registering contracts in July will not stop player managers from negotiating with other clubs beforehand. Once a player has his mind set on a new club, it will be difficult to change it.

  3. I’m having a bit of fun, and agree he’s probably a good administrator. That’s why I thought nothing of his Benji gaffe. It’s irrelevant in the scheme of things, but does highlight that he needs to immerse himself more in the game. My problem is really more to do with those above him. I’m not so sure he was picked to run the game. I think John Grant likes that too much. I wish David luck.

    On transfers, it’s fine for players, managers and (rival) clubs to have a dialogue in my view. No problem at all. They have to. They’re not employees, but contractors, and must therefore look out for themselves. At the same time, it is a team game, and material disruptions like the Papalii signing at such an early stage (or not, who knows now?) needs to be considered in that light.

    Just as long as everyone knows there are no ‘done deals’ until the transfer window is operational.

    Don’t know about you, but I can hardly wait for next week!

    • I think you are correct, he will run the NRL as a business and John Grant will run the game. This is going to be very different from the Gallop days.

      I think the transfer window will come in sooner rather than later, if for no other reason than to appease the fans and media.

      I think it every year, but this year in particular with the drugs scandal and Barba issue, I can’t wait til we have some actual footy to talk about.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s